To Save or Not to Save?

To Save or Not to Save?

I was talking with a friend recently that works the customer service phones for the company she is with. She mentioned that her company expects her to solve any customer's problem in three minutes or less. That sounds like a policy created by someone trying to save a few bucks while thousands of potential sales walk down the street to the nearest competitor. She did mention, however, that earlier that day she had taken a call from a customer that was a personal friend of the founder. After running into several brick walls with the fulfillment department she mentioned the issue to her manager and was told, "Do whatever it takes. Just make that customer happy." Apparently the policy at this particular company is "3 minutes for customers. Whatever it takes for friends of the boss."

As wrong as that policy may be, at some level every company probably needs to come up with some criteria for deciding which customers are worth saving and, more importantly, ensure that the best customers get all the attention they need. But how do you decide who the best customers are?

The chart that accompanies this post was taken from a recent article in the alumni magazine from my graduate school. The article provides some great suggestions for setting your criteria. You can read it here.

One word of caution: as you try to determine who your most profitable customers are don't limit the analysis only to past purchases. A customer who buys little from you but tells hundreds of friends can mean much more to your bottom line than a customer that spends a lot but never tells another soul. That pauper may actually be a prince!

The growth of your business will be determined by what your customers say about it. Do you know what they are saying? Learn more
Submitted by Chris Kaday (not verified) on Sat, 05/26/2007 - 7:22am.

Love that chart – really gets the point across. However there is one important point readers should consider. Is not just about customer value and profit - what about opportunity? Usually customer segmentation is carried out in terms of actual order value over time. However this can be very misleading. Of course companies who spend mega bucks with you and are profitable should be treated as ‘royalty’ but what about large corporates with massive buying power who happen to be tiny spenders with you – right now. If you do the analysis in terms of future opportunity as well as immediate revenue and profit a very different picture will emerge – try it and see.

Submitted by Charles H. Green (not verified) on Mon, 02/05/2007 - 8:07pm.

You're quite right about the hazards of running a very cost-focused customer service operation. FOr one thing, as you point out, you often don't know when you're talking to a friend of the boss. And, you often don't know whether the person you're talking to has the power to refer you to many others.

Running customer service with rigid timelines has two big things wrong.

First, it assumes customer service ought to be run as a cost center. In truth, it ought to be partially funded by marketing, as an opportunistic lead genearation part of the business.

Really good people interacting with customers, given education and empowerment, are in the best position of all to make snap judgments about where to extend time and attention, and to make exceptions. No policy in the world can substitute for good judgment on the front lines. Rewarding people on narrow efficiency measurements, and running the operation like a cost center, sends all the wrong messages.

Second, as mentioned above, running custoemr service as if it had no marketing implications hurts revenue. The extra time spent on a person can have huge ripple ramifications. An enlightened company would either co-fund the customer service function, or staff it itself part time, or in some way or other get involved. Instead, too many companies kid themselves that cold, fill-in-the-multiple-choice service analyses fulfill the function. Nothing succeeds like really talkign to customers.


Seeds from the blogworld
We search the business blog world looking for posts that illustrate principles, or "Seeds", that if followed, or "planted", will help small businesses grow. We list them here for your convenience. Enjoy.

Blogroll